Florida Lawmaker: No Tax Credit to Movies with Gays, “Non-Traditional Family Values”

With 45 states offering tax incentives to lure movie and TV productions, there’s a lot of competition for film and video money. But that doesn’t seem to bother Florida lawmaker Stephen Precourt who would like a bonus 2% tax incentive to film in Florida yanked from productions that depict “non-traditional family values” along with smoking, drinking and “gratuitous” violence.

Wait, I thought Republicans were against government interference in business and opposed the idea of a nanny state dictating behavior and thoughts.

And so what exactly is “non-traditional” anyway?

Florida Gov. Charlie Cris has an explanation. Sort of.

Let me define it in the positive. A traditional family is a marriage between a man and a woman. That’s traditional.

Hmmm, so would the Partridge Family be a traditional family? What about Three Men and a Baby? Scarface, Bad Boys and Miami Vice would not have qualified for the extra tax break under Precourt’s version of the Florida’s Entertainment Industry Economic Development Act. Neither would have Pirates of the Caribbean or Avatar which were high budget features that did not shoot in Florida. What about Nip/Tuck? Not exactly traditional or suitable for a 5-year old to watch!

While Florida already offer a “family-friendly”tax credit, Precourt’s proposal ups the ante to exclude certain content:

A certified production determined by the Commissioner of Film and Entertainment, with the advice of the Florida Film and Entertainment Advisory Council, to be family-friendly…Family-friendly productions are those that have cross-generational appeal; would be considered suitable for viewing by children age 5 or older…and do not exhibit or imply any act of smoking, sex, nudity, nontraditional family values, gratuitous violence, or vulgar or profane language. Under the current incentive program, review of the final release version is not required and nontraditional family values, gratuitous violence, and implied acts do not exclude a film from receiving this additional credit.

Brian Winfield, Director of Communications for Equality Florida told me that

The term non-traditional is limiting and Equality Florida will do anything we can to work with our legislative allies to strike that language.

Over one-third of Florida children are being raised in single-parent families, while there are other family structures that include children being raised by extended family members and in foster care, as well in blended families. These dynamics also include LGBT families.

Asked if productions with gay characters should get the tax credit, Precourt said:

That would not be the kind of thing I’d say that we want to invest public dollars in.

Well, here in Los Angeles, CA we have these things called “film lots” and “soundstages” where anything can be created, even Florida! And according to Film LA which I spoke to today:

There is no level of government oversight here. We do not become involved in First Amendment issues.

[HT Think Progress]

5 Responses to "Florida Lawmaker: No Tax Credit to Movies with Gays, “Non-Traditional Family Values”"
Teddy Partridge | Monday March 8, 2010 01:26 pm 1

Unless Governor Crist and his newly acquired Mrs — whose business is making costume beards, I shit you not — become procreative, I have bad news for them from the Prop 8 trial: their marriage is no more legitimate in the eyes of the fundies than one between two dudes.


Elana Levin | Monday March 8, 2010 01:44 pm 2

Thanks for covering this story! It’s a real “headspload” situation. I guess if that lawmaker wants to undermine his local economy…


grumpus | Monday March 8, 2010 04:50 pm 3

“and do not exhibit or imply any act of smoking, sex, nudity, nontraditional family values, gratuitous violence, or vulgar or profane language”

In other words, films nobody makes and nobody wants to watch. Also, “gratuitous” is just as arbitrary/meaningless as “nontraditional.”


dakine01 | Tuesday March 9, 2010 05:22 am 4

We’re talking a lot of Florida based movies with a Florida theme.

And I think most movies with a Florida based theme are going to include aspects that this asshat finds objectionable.

There goes the Florida based movie industry.


floridatogether | Tuesday March 9, 2010 06:20 am 5

Bill Pending in Florida Legislature would discourage depiction of “non-traditional” families in films
Florida Together Urges Florida Legislature to Remove Provision
from Proposed Bill

House Bill 697 and Senate Bill 1430, filed in January for the 2010 Legislative Session in Tallahassee, would revise the state’s financial incentive program to provide tax credits to the film industry, but an additional “family friendly” credit would be provided only if film makers censor films to avoid certain subject matters, including depiction of “non-traditional family values”. The provision could cause filmmakers who film in Florida to avoid depictions of non-traditional families such as gay families, single-parent families, families where grandkids are raised by their grandparents, etc.

Real-life families come in all shapes and sizes. Marginalizing single-parent families, gay families and other non-traditional families by instituting 1950′s-style movie censorship does nothing to support real-life families or help Florida’s struggling economy.

Florida Together learned of the problematic language after the House Economic Development Policy Committee voted unanimously to move the House bill out of that committee last Wednesday on March 3, 2010.

We then immediately engaged some of Florida Together’s local member organizations, such as SAVE Dade and Palm Beach County Human Rights Council, to oppose this provision of the proposed bill, making use of positive relationships with legislators from their local regions.

Since learning of the problematic language last Wednesday, we communicated with several legislators, including some bill sponsors, and continued to do so as recently as today. What we learned from the sponsors we’ve spoken to, including Democrats and Republicans, was that each expressed surprise and concern when we told them the bill included the “non-traditional family” language, and each agreed to look into this right away.

According to the Palm Beach Post, Chairwoman Jennifer Carroll, R-Fleming Island, who praised the bill for promoting “positive social aspects” when her committee voted for the bill, later she didn’t know about the prohibition on family-friendly credits, and that the language should be changed.

“What someone could see as a traditional family value could be different for another person,” Carroll was quoted as saying in the Post. “We’ll have to delve into that.”

Florida Together will be working with our members and partners on trying to get the problematic language changed through the committee process over the next few days. If that does not resolve the problem, our community and organizations will need to work together to draw attention and opposition to the problematic language in this bill.

Ted Howard, Executive Director

Florida Together is the advocacy arm of Florida Together Federation, a federation of local organizations. Florida Together’s website is coming soon. In the meantime, if you want to learn more about Florida Together Federation, our 501(c)3 arm, visit that website at http://outfl.org/, or visit the Facebook page at http://www.facebook.com/home.php?#/group.php?gid=48497576155. Please note that Florida Together and Florida Together Federation are affiliated, but separate and distinct legal entities.


Sorry but the comments are closed on this post

Get the Most out of FDL

Become a Founding Member today

Build our community

Get great discounts

Keep us independent

Close